From Richard Klein’s Facebook Wall

FOUR PARADIGMATIC REACTIONS TO THE POSITIVE TRANSFERENCE OF ‘BEING IN LOVE WITH THE ANALYST’

1) Josef Breuer: When confronted with the pseudo-pregnancy of his patient, Bertha Pappenheim, he stopped the therapy and ran for the hills.
2) Sigmund Freud: In his Selbstdarstellung, Freud mentions that when a patient awoke from hypnosis, she threw her arms around him in an embrace. He knew that this manifestation of ‘being in love’ was not to him personally, but was a result of a transference, which is necessary for every analysis.
3) Carl Jung: Sabina Spielrein declared her love for him, so he had an affair with her.
4) Sandor Ferenczi: The ideal for him is to hug and kiss every patient, and then engage in some kind of a ‘mutual analysis’

So we have 4 typical reactions to a positive transference:
1) Flight; 2) a cool objective consideration and detachment, 3) being taken in by the positive transference and having an affair, and lastly,4) by indulging in a love affair with every patient.
The first two reactions are some type of a refusal. The first one being of the particular, the second being a refusal in general or universal. The next reaction is an acceptance in the particular. The last reaction is an acceptance in the general. These 4 reactions could be placed on the Aristotelian Square of Opposition.

UNIVERSAL AFFIRMATIVE =
Every S is P
Ferenczi’s position: Hug and kiss every patient and then have a “mutual analysis”

UNIVERSAL NEGATIVE= No S is P
Freud: Do not have sexual relation with any patient. Their ‘being in love with me’ is a necessary result of every transference

PARTICULAR AFFIRMATIVE=
Some is P
Jung: It’s okay to have an affair with at least one of your patients, Sabina Spielrein, for instance. l.

PARTICULAR NEGATIVE=
Some S is not P
Josef Breuer, his patient Bertha Pappenheim, has a pseudo-pregnancy and claims that she is having Breuer’s child. Breuer stops the therapy and flees in great anxiety.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s